Merry Christmas from Carl Malamud (and generous citizens)!

Following up on previous posts (here and here) about the deal between Amazon and the National Archives which makes DVD’s of NARA’s video holdings available for purchase on Amazon (at a price, of course) . . . a December 19 post over on BoingBoing put out a call for people to purchase the DVDs from Amazon and send them to Carl Malamud, who will digitize them and put them online for free public access via “YouTube, the Internet Archive, and to our own rsync/ftp public domain stock footage library.”

Per a comment from Carl (who kindly linked to my posts on the topic for background–thanks!) as of December 23 all the needed videos had been purchased and donated, and so will be made available online soon. While this is a great example of creativity and crowdsourcing and we all owe Carl our thanks for his persistence on this, I’m sure we all also wish this wasn’t necessary. The issue of whether these NARA partnerships with commercial companies are the best way to support the digitization of their holdings is perhaps not as easy to resolve as we might hope. Yes, we all want NARA to make free public online access to their holdings a priority but the cost of digitization is competing with many other equally important priorities in NARA’s limited budget. I am sure that David Ferriero will give serious thought before entering into another of these kinds of digitization partnerships, and I hope that he will be open to exploring other options. There are lots of dedicated, creative, public-spirited people out there who have ideas about how to help NARA make its holdings more available to the public. I hope Mr. Ferriero reaches out and involves them as he works on developing new strategic directions for the National Archives.

Be Sociable, Share!

3 thoughts on “Merry Christmas from Carl Malamud (and generous citizens)!”

  1. In contrast, see this article about the Library of Congress’ digitization project which puts “thousands of books online”: http://www.america.gov/st/educ-english/2009/December/20091223172644xlrennef0.264187.html

    Note that “A $2 million grant from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation inaugurated the LOC book digitization project.” It’s possible (even probable) that NARA is not eligible for such grants, but other non-profit organizations are.

    Also note that: “Other federal agencies such as the Department of the Treasury and the Government Printing Office are sending books and documents through the Library of Congress scanning center (PDF, 90KB). It’s “an opportunity to demonstrate government transparency,” Kahle said.” I’m sure NARA has its own scanning facilities that are perfectly adequate, but it would be nice to read about a comparable effort on NARA’s part to do this kind of collaboration. It really does seem as if I read stories like this about LOC all the time–how much they do to make their collections accessible, digitization, etc. Is LOC really doing more or do they just do a better job of getting publicity?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.